Featured Cocktails

And at the end of each tour we ask our guests, which of the several cocktails they tried, was their favorite? 
Check back here often for recipes and pro tips from the mixologists who created them.

Be cocktail curious and drink outside the box. Cheers!


Benvenuto Invernale

Denmark on High

This aptly named cocktail (Italian for wintry welcome) warmed the souls and won the hearts of our guests. It was the perfect finish to a tour on a frigid January evening.

1.5 oz bacon-washed gin
1 oz Amaro Lucano
.5 oz maple syrup
.25 oz Solerno Blood Orange Liquor
3 dashes rosemary tincture

Stir over ice, strain, and serve in a rocks glass over one large ice cube. Garnish with a sprig of fresh rosemary.

PRO TIP: Get into Denmark and order this delicious cocktail while it's on their seasonal menu.


Nocino Negroni

Paulie Gee's

In this riff on the classic cocktail, Adele substituted the sweet vermouth with Watershed's Nocino, a black walnut liquor, that created a complex and beautifully balanced cocktail that became this week's fan favorite. 

1.5 oz Vim and Petal Gin
.75 oz Watershed Nocino liquor
.75 oz Campari

Stir ingredients over ice, strain, and serve in a rocks glass over one large rock. Garnish with orange peel.

PRO TIP: Although the classic negroni calls for equal proportions of the three ingredients, Adele doubled the amount of gin to compensate for the bold flavors of the Nocino liquor.


The Rebennack

The Bottle Shop

Although it was created only a few years ago in New Orleans by Chris Hannah of Arnaud's French 75, this delicious cocktail is quickly becoming a modern classic.

1.5 oz Rye
.75 oz Amaro Averna (italian bitter liquor)
.5 oz Rhum Clément Créole Shrub (orange liquor)
2 dashes Peychaud's bitters

Stir ingredients over ice, strain, and serve up in coupe or cocktail glass. Garnish with orange peel.

PRO TIP: Jordan impressed us all and upped the ante for this cocktail by flaming and expressing a lemon peel over the cocktail.


Gold Rush

The Table

The Gold Rush is a modern spin on a classic whiskey sour (or is it a whiskey version of the Bee's Knees? It's hard to say). Jen added Cointreau to her cocktail to bring out the citrus flavors and add a little more sweetness and topped it with a splash of soda to create a boozy, yet refreshing, fan favorite.

2 oz Watershed bourbon
.25 oz Cointreau
.25 oz fresh lemon juice
.125 – .25 oz honey syrup (to taste)
splash of soda water

Build in a rocks glass, stir and top with a splash of soda.

PRO TIP: Honey syrup can be made at home the same way you'd make simple syrup. 1:1 (water to honey), bring to a boil and let cool.



Thurber's Bar

Heather shared a new cocktail with us which will appear on Thurber's fall menu. She asked our guests to help her come up with a name and after several ideas they landed (for now) on Snap-teaze — referencing the ginger snap cookie and tea flavors that are so beautifully balanced with the rye in this cocktail.  

2 oz rye whiskey
.5 oz liquor 43
4 – 5 dashes of Angostura bitters
Top with ginger kambucha

Build in a rocks glass and garnish with candied ginger.

PRO TIP: You can bring out some additional amazing flavors by using black walnut or orange bitters instead of Angostura.


The Pamala — A.K.A. Even Cowgirls get the Blues

Denmark on High

Garry created this unique cocktail for our birthday girl and it still needed a name, hence the Pamala! Fruity and delicious, the Pamala was our final cocktail of the tour and an immediate fan favorite.

1.5 oz Watershed bourbon
.5 oz house ginger liqueur
.75 oz fresh lemon juice
.75 oz honey syrup
1 teaspoon house blueberry ginger jam
3 dashes house orange bitters

Combine all ingredients, shake and double strain into a rocks glass. Add one large ice cube and garnish with fresh blueberries.

PRO TIP: Fresh and house-made ingredients are key to this cocktail. They could be substituted but get into Denmark on High and ask for this cocktail by name, you can thank us later.


Court Reporter

Blind Lady Tavern

Seth started our tour with one his original recipes — the Court Reporter. Despite having several other wonderful cocktails on the tour, this refreshing cocktail was so delicious that it stayed on the minds of all of our guests and became this week's "fan favorite".

1 oz Gin
.75 oz fresh lime juice
.5 oz peach liquor
.5 oz house tonic syrup

Combine all ingredients, shake and strain into a flute or coupe and top with pink bubbles.

PRO TIP: Do not use peach schnapps instead of peach liquor, the low quality will be noticed. Also, homemade tonic, while preferred, is not required — most good liquor stores will carry tonic syrup.


The White Lady

Thurber's Bar

This classic cocktail is refreshing and light and stole the hearts of many who thought they wouldn't like a cocktail made with egg whites. It dates back to pre-prohibition times and is still a classic for a very good reason — it's delicious!

1 oz Watershed Gin
1 oz Cointreau
1/2 fresh squeezed lemon
1 egg white

Combine all ingredients and shake vigorously. Strain and serve up in a martini glass. Garnish with a lemon twirl

PRO TIP: Heather used Watershed Four Peel Gin to enhance the citrusy finish of this cocktail.



Mexican 75

Blind Lady Tavern

Sami started our tour with this delicious twist on the classic French 75. 

2 oz Blanco tequila
1 oz fresh lime juice
.5 oz agave syrup

Shake and double strain into a flute and fill with sparkling wine.

PRO TIP: Simple syrup can be used if you don't have agave on hand

The Last Call

Soul at the Joseph

This refreshing tequila-based spin on the classic Last Word was our first cocktail of the tour but stuck in everyone's mind to win as our Sunday Funday fan favorite.

.75 oz Blanco tequila
.75 oz Aperol
.75 oz Yellow Chartreuse
.75 oz fresh lime juice
simple syrup (as needed)

Shake and double strain using a Hawthorn strainer and pour the cocktail through a mesh strainer to remove all of the ice. Serve up in a coupe or cocktail glass

PRO TIP: The lime juice was particularly tart so .25 oz of simple was needed. Adjust amount to taste.



The Bottle Shop

Barbara served up classic Manhattans three ways to showcase the importance of the main ingredient — whiskey, and show how it influences the cocktail. While the bourbon and scotch versions were enjoyed, it was the rye that stood out and won as fan favorite.

2 oz Old Overholt Rye
1 oz Carpano Antica Formula Vermouth
Two dashes Angostura bitters
Lemon peel (for garnish)
Luxardo cherries (for garnish)

Stir* ingredients over ice and serve up in coupe or cocktail glass. Express the lemon peel over the cocktail and garnish with Luxardo cherries.

PRO TIP: Splurge and get these exact ingredients for your bar. You can thank us later.

*A proper Manhattan should never be shaken.


Corpse Reviver No. 2

Blind Lady Tavern

The Corpse Reviver No. 2 was originally concocted as a hangover remedy, of which Harry Craddock, cataloging it in the “Savoy Cocktail Book” in 1930, wrote, “To be taken before 11 am, or whenever steam and energy are needed.” He also famously cautioned: “Four of these taken in swift succession will quickly unrevive the corpse again.”

.75 oz Gordon's Gin
.75 oz Cocchi Americano
.75 oz Dry Curaçao
.75 oz fresh lemon juice
dash of Absinthe

Shake and serve up in a coupe or cocktail glass.

PRO TIP: Use a mister to spray the Absinthe over a chilled glass before pouring the cocktail. This will help control the amount of Absinthe in the drink as well as incorporating it in the cocktail.


The Oriental Cocktail

The Bar at Hyde Park

Originally published in the Savoy Cocktail Book, this classic cocktail is said to have been created by a man who nearly died of a fever and gave this recipe to the doctor who saved his life as a token of his appreciation. 

1.5 oz Rittenhouse Rye
.75 oz sweet vermouth
.75 oz Cointreau Orange Liqueur
.5 oz fresh lime juice

Shake and serve up in a cocktail glass and garnish with a Luxardo cherry or twist of orange peel.

PRO TIP: for your garnish, wrap an orange peel around the cherry and skewer both together. 


Blood and sand


Named after a Rudolph Valentino movie about bullfighting, this classic Scotch cocktail is delicious when it's perfectly balanced but can easily fail, so precise measurements are a must. 

.75 oz Dewer's Blended Scotch
.75 oz Carpano Antica Formula Sweet Vermouth
.75 oz Cherry Heering
.75 oz orange juice

Shake and serve up in a coupe or cocktail glass and garnish with a twist of orange peel.

PRO TIP(s): Using the brands listed makes a difference. and buy a bottle of Cherry Herring now while you can still find it in Ohio. 

Plea Deal

Blind Lady Tavern

This incredible cocktail was so perfectly balanced that it won the hearts, and tastes, of our guests — who didn't think they liked gin, until they tried Seth's Plea Deal.

1.5 oz London Dry Gin
1 oz lime
.75 oz Manzanilla Sherry
.5 oz dill syrup
2 oz Saison

Build the cocktail in a rocks glass. Garnish with a sprig of fresh dill.

PRO TIP: Add ice to glass at the end so as to not dilute the drink too much.

Hemingway Daiquiri

Denmark on High

Simple. Classic. Refreshing. Delicious. And perfect for a hot summer afternoon.

2 oz white rum
.75 oz fresh lime juice
.25 oz Maraschino liquor
.25 oz fresh grapefruit juice

Shake and serve up in a chilled cocktail glass or coupe. Garnish with a slice of lime.

PRO TIP: Ty served up this classic cocktail by double straining it: using a Hawthorn strainer and pouring the cocktail through a mesh strainer to remove all of the ice. 

I was surprised how easy-going and fun the CCCT was! So much so, that I’ve been twice! (Downtown & Short North) The hosts are gracious and let the group enjoy their time together. My friends and I sipped specialty cocktails made from spirits we never knew existed as well as some of our old favorites. There were plenty of great appetizers, too! The timing is perfect as we strolled the Short North after the tour and had more to eat and drink! My husband and I get inspired by the cool bartenders and try to mix our own cocktails at home. I highly recommend these tours!!
— Leslee I. — Worthington, OH


Soul at the Joseph

This classic cocktail has been enjoyed since the 1920s and for good reason — it's delicious!

2 oz VS Cognac
.75 oz Gran Marnier (may substitute Cointreau or Triple Sec)
.75 oz Lemon juice

Shake and serve up in a chilled cocktail glass or coupe. Garnish with an orange peel.

PRO TIP: The classic Sidecar recipe is a simple 2:1:1 proportioned cocktail. Ian upped the booziness with more Cognac. Save money and use VS Cognac for this citrusy cocktail.


A Brief and Wondrous History

Denmark on High

This delicious and complex cocktail was created by Francisco for Denmark's Summer cocktail menu. 

1 oz tamarind infused Appleton
1 oz Pineapple-mango Brugal
.25 oz Turbino
3 drops Jerk bitters

Shake with ice, infuse smoke and serve neat in a chilled rocks glass. 
Garnish with dried mango and pineapple.

PRO TIP: unless you own a smoke gun, go to Denmark while this amazing cocktail is still on the menu.


Madre Tierra

Paulie Gee's

This refreshing cocktail was created by Dom as a tribute to Earth Day 2017.

1.5 oz Ilegal Jovan Mezcal
.5 oz Green Chartreuse
.5 oz simple syrup
4 slices cucumber
Small bunch of arugula
Black pepper

Muddle 3 slices of cucumber and arugula in a rocks glass and fill with crushed ice, In a shaker, combine all ingredients, add ice and shake until cold. Strain and garnish with the remaining cucumber slice and fresh-ground black pepper.